Which happened to be a sponge (new, of course) covered in homemade frosting.
"This must be Angel Food Cake!" my husband said when he tried cutting his fork through it. I'm pretty sure he caught on almost immediately that it wasn't a real cake.
The teen though scooped off and ate several forkfuls of icing before she hit the sponge layer, her face twisting up in a look of pure disgust, then the plate went flying across the table. Joke well played Allison!
Did you play any pranks for April Fools Day, or did you happen to get pranked yourself?